Unfortunately, I do not like the results. Goes on light, almost gray-like. Lacks opacity, and vibrancy. Unless it's like the old-school Maybelline eyeliner that we had to light (warm/melt) with a lighter. Then wiped off fairly easily to be considered "long-wear".

This replaced my long time favorite eyeliner. This is my new favorite because of the silky smooth application that glides on. Most eyeliners irritate my eyes, but not this one! I wear contacts and have seasonal allergies and this eyeliner doesn't budge, crease or transfer. The formula lasts all day, feels like nothing is there and is very easy to apply. I also like that I never have to sharpen it! I have oily lids and this has the staying power! Believe me, I have tried ALL of the "best" eyeliners and this one takes the cake! I hope they never change the formula or discontinue this stellar product!
Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/

This is the ONLY black pencil eye liner I will wear! Creamy super black color and smooth consistency are perfect for adding dimensional and smoky looks. Once it's dry it stays put! Its waterproof formula is THE best!! Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/

It is creamy and glides on. The best staying power for the waterline .

I bought this a few months ago and I love it! But now I’m out… And I have work in a few days… And since it takes longer to receive the item I was wondering what kind of pencil this is? Why does it glide on so easily? Seriously I barely touch it to my eye and I get such great pigment! It’s the only eyeliner I can use… I want to buy one in person where I live but I don’t know what kind it is… Is it kohl?? I’m purchasing another one right now but until it comes I need some thing to wear to work… Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/

I gave up on eyeliner years ago because of my sensitive, watery eyes. Every "waterproof" liner would disappear quickly. I received this liner free with purchase so I tried it. IT DIDN'T MOVE! I couldn't believe that my liner looked exactly the same at the end of a long day.
I strongly recommend this liner, especially for watery eyes. Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/

This was a free gift with my purchase. Great liner and stays out like it says. The day I tried it, I fell asleep in full makeup, woke up the next morning and the liner looked perfect. Even though I had rubbed one eye and smeared my eyeshadow, the liner was still in place! Good stuff. Goes in smooth and easy.
Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/

I bought this a few months ago and it is so amazing!! it works exactly as its supposed too.
Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/

I live for a khol liner that will last in the waterline without setting it in place. This eyeliner lasted me all day without any smudging and barely any fading. The color is ultra black and I think the price of this eyeliner is very reasonable because you get a lot for your money!! Reviewed on https://sigmabeauty.com/