Sure it goes on great. But, after a couple hours it would flake off, leaving spots on the lash line with NO LINER . Yeah you can sharpen this pencil but, do not expect that to go well. Your no longer able to use it without it breaking, or even finish application to one eye before having to sharpen once again . Not to mention the mess it's created. There are many $6.00 drug store liners better then this one. Do not waste your money on this liner not worth it.

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

You are not able to sharpen this......what you see is it.........definitely will not be buying anymore.

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

I agree, totally not value for money. Wears well but honestly for the amount you get I would rather spend the extra on say tom Ford as the cost would be the same. I will not purchase again or recommend

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

I love Killer Liner in Killer Black. It glides on easy without tugging. The lightweight formula doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. It is perfect to use on the waterline.

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

I have no idea how anyone doesn't love these! I have five shades and they apply smoothly, sharpen well and stay on all day. I have backups of these on hand. They're easily my favorite.

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

I started having problems with the eyeliner that I wore for years. Urban decay started running into my eyes and clouding my contacts. By the end of the day half my eyeliner was gone. I also used Marc Jacobs eyeliners but he's discontinuing his makeup line.
I tried one Too Faced eyeliner and immediately went back to Ulta and bought 3 more colors. This eyeliner is the bomb. Goes on easily and stays until I take it off with makeup remover. I have fallen asleep with it on and woke up with it fresh looking the next morning. The only complaint I have is that I go through it very quickly. I have no problem with sharpening it as others have stated. I use my Charlotte Tillbury sharpener and it sharpens very easily. I have to sharpen it every 2-3 uses to keep a pointed end to create a nice fluid line. The pencil is not that big to begin with so I am going through the Plum color my favorite for green eyes, makes them pop rapidly. Too Face, consider making your pencils larger please! That is my only complaint other wise a great eyeliner with many choices in color!

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

This eyeliner pencil was very disappointing. It did not last 24 hrs for me. The pencil did not last long at all.

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

No joke, I love this eyeliner. It is so smooth and it glides on super easy. I
This is my new favorite!

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

This pencil is very good but what I didn't like is that all the product you get is what's visible and you can't sharpened it. Wish they can take this into consideration and make improvements to it.

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com

Goes on smooth and stays all day! I love it!!!

This product was reviewed on toofaced.com